Infinite Punishment For a Limited Life? How Can This Be Fair?

in this episode of the cross-examination we're going to ask you the hardest questions about hell ready Allah despite being the master of the entire universe why is he making such violent and harsh threats for a person who is not even a speck in the universe those who do a great amount of Good Deeds during their lifetime but do not believe in Allahu will they also go to hell why is Hell Eternal based on the brief life in this world will Eternal punishment be a fair price for wrongdoings is there really a place called hell can you prove it there is a place called hell and the proof for it is logical for instance say there's a king and in his land a man comes and starts insulting him and says I

don't recognize the authority of this King now in his land even though there is no prison just for that man a prison will be built for example when an unbeliever says to Allah you don't perform these actions everything is futile everything is a coincidence by saying such things he is rejecting the existence of Allah after committing such a sin and showing such an insulting attitude a hell will be made just for that man and for the oppressors who abuse innocent people when we look at some previous oppressors they slaughtered thousands of innocent people and yet they still died in Easy death to provide Justice to the innocent and Punishment to the guilty of course there will be a place called

hell for example has it ever crossed your mind why is mankind set up courts almost everywhere on Earth there are thousands of Courts we shout justice justice justice what does justice mean it means to get someone what he deserves saying about the one who gave you this sense of Justice that he will not ensure that they will get what they deserve is illogical why because the sense of justice that's in US is a characteristic given to us by Allah in the first place it is unimaginable to think that the one who gave us this characteristic sense of justice would be unfair therefore Allah the almighty will sentence those who deserve punishment in the court he has established and those who have a

claim their claims will be heard we see that a tyrant kills thousands of Innocents in this day and age yet he dies in Easy death claims of countless innocence the agony of mothers who will provide Justice to them the Tyrant leaves the world without paying any price for the lives he has taken saying about the one who has infinite Justice he will not punish a human being for crimes he has committed he has not established a court for that is irrational and inconsistent so heaven and hell are both present there Allah will give everyone what they deserve according to their deeds why is Hell Eternal let it be a hundred thousand years or a hundred billion years for mistakes made in this brief life

on planet Earth would Eternal punishment be a just price to pay of course it would be just the punishment is not for the time duration of the crime the punishment is given based on the nature of the crime we can't make that distinction today a man who commits murder can be sentenced to life in prison instantly what is a life sentence never ending that means this guy is going to be in jail for the rest of his life there are sentences in the Justice systems established by mankind that are 320 to 600 years long why is he punished with a sentence like that also the man committed this crime in a limited time a very short time why is he punished for his entire life for a crime committed in a very

short time we don't argue about that why because the nature of his crime is serious that is why he is punished like that in other words the punishment is not for the duration of the crime but for the nature of the crime what kind of crime would deserve an eternal punishment in hell we can give many examples to explain this I will use this as an example if you slap me now I'll slap you back we can fight but it will be over by tomorrow we will get over it one way or another we won't be punished for it however if you slap a police officer or a police commissioner you'll get serious punishment the two slaps mentioned above are not the same the degree of punishment will increase or decrease

depending on who you are insulting there's somebody who created the universe and has infinite power and greatness it creates and controls everything by himself and yet the unbeliever comes out and says he doesn't control anything and does not acknowledge his creator he says he God doesn't do anything good for me he says he's not the one who is keeping me alive right now he commits a monstrous crime by claiming the reason behind his actions is not his own but others if you insult or slap just a policeman you'll face severe consequences but having an insulting attitude to the Lord of all the policemen the lord of the entire universe surely the consequence must be an eternal punishment in hell

since you challenge and taunt an eternal entity you deserve eternity of punishment that is because the names and attributes of Allah the almighty are Eternal when you insult him in reality you are insulting an eternal entity therefore the punishment for a crime you commit against an eternal entity will be Eternal it's pretty straightforward will people who do many Good Deeds but don't believe in Allah go to hell good and evil are relative Concepts we call a person good however is he really a good person he might be good from our perspective is he really a good person in the eyes of Allah this can be explained with an example imagine there is a king he gives all his fortune to a man and says

go to this Village and take care of the needs of all the poor people in it that man goes there with everything the king gave him and does Good Deeds these Good Deeds all Belong To The King why because to acquire those deeds required the king's wealth did he have something similar no the king could have accomplished those deeds through someone else if the man who carried out those deeds now said the king didn't do any of these Good Deeds I did them by myself surely he must be punished in the eyes of the king he seems like a good person to the people since he's the one who apparently carried out the Good Deeds that is what good is in the eyes of the people since he disregarded the King by

saying all these Deeds are done by me and didn't give the king his due credit of course he deserves to be punished in the eyes of the king just like this example one can say I am the sole reason for this good deed when one says I did this all by myself he needs to build this statement on Solid Ground for you to perform that good deed the solar system needs to function correctly are you keeping it the solar system in order no the world needs oxygen so one can complete one's actions are you supplying that oxygen no your organs need to work properly so you can perform that deed at that exact moment do you keep them working properly no there is someone else who is providing all of these

Necessities so you can do those good deeds and yet if you still say I am doing this alone I'm the sole doer of this good deed surely you will come across as a good person to the people but in the eyes of the one who supplies you with all the conditions necessary for you to do those good Deeds you deserve to be punished people may think of you as a good person but since you rejected the actual performer by saying I did this you are guilty in the eyes of God the situation for a Muslim is the opposite a Muslim does Good Deeds but he knows that goodness really comes from Allah he says that the actual performer the actual creator of that action is Allah because of his thinking and attitude he

will be rewarded by Allah the almighty he will be worthy of a reward by Allah why because he didn't conceal who did the actual work he didn't cover it up he didn't deny it he did it himself yet he said Allah made me do that because he is conscious of that the situation of a Muslim compared to a non-muslim is quite the opposite Allah the master of the entire universe why is he making such huge and violent threats to a tiny human being who's not even a speck in the universe if this is some sort of guidance couldn't he have used a different method the value of something can't be calculated by how it physically is we must understand this saying man is relatively small compared to the universe

does not diminish the value of human beings as a matter of fact your eyes are tiny containing very small amounts of material however for you they're worth more than all the planets mountains and oceans well just because something is small doesn't mean it's worthless the qualities it has determines its real value if we look at the characteristics of human beings we see that humans are very sophisticated for instance life understanding comprehension knowledge intelligence looking at these characteristics just as he acts freely in the universe Allah will surely teach such a noble being what he should or shouldn't do you say is how some sort of Education method couldn't it have been different I

think it's an outstanding education method we put up signs on switchboard saying caution danger of death right to show its seriousness there's even a skull symbol on it it's a pretty strong deterrent for humans do we ask why are you trying to scare me from electric shock like this for no reason do you get it is there no other way a simpler or different method to keep me away from it no how can one say this if it doesn't warn you strongly enough you may be tempted to take the risk it scares you so sternly so you don't go anywhere near it likewise Allah also cares about humans a lot he warns you from getting closer to hell just like you're warned about the switchboard to not go near it this in

fact is a great Mercy if a child goes near a heater the mother will say to him stay away from it or you'll get burnt If the child gets too close she may hit him so he may never go near the heater again we don't say heartless woman why are you always trying to keep your child away from the heater so violently why is that the mother behaves this way out of compassion to protect her child from great harm at the beginning of this episode we said no hell no justice so if there is Hell where's the mercy first if there is no hell it brings forth the question where is Allah's Mercy why because the rights of thousands of oppressed are being violated when someone is wronged what do we say punish this

cruel man is violated the rights of others punish him with what he deserves if that guy roams free then we will say where is the Justice well I say isn't it compassion to provide Justice to millions of oppressed people in fact Justice itself is compassion if you say don't punish them I'll ask where is your mercy millions of Innocents have been wronged and you don't want the person who is responsible to be punished I'll ask again where is your mercy because of this Allah is both merciful and just so what should we do to stay away from hell up until now we have been talking about hell however when you use the word hell too many times and talk only about Allah's punishment believing that Allah

is only punishing in Hell or burning the ones who deserve that does not reflect the truth since Allah is also infinitely merciful and Allah says my Mercy surpasses my wrath we've talked a lot about these things we've talked a lot about the hidden causes of hell but Allah wants to put us into heaven Allah is so compassionate you can look at the examples of how compassionate animals on Earth are to their offsprings you can also look at your mother's compassion for you their compassion is not even a single drop compared to the infinite compassion of Allah someone says God only sent you to this world so he can burn you in the Hereafter this is just the devil's game if that was the case Allah

would have burnt us anyway right he could have punished this directly in hell and we could do nothing about it however Allah put us in this world and he wants to put us into heaven Allah shows us his love and affection everywhere Allah is just and his Justice is infinite since his Justice is infinite he will take into account all the mistakes to keep us away from making those mistakes he sent prophets books and Scholars so that we may find the right path do not understand from Allah will burn us that he will punish us continuously this is not true because Allah has revealed an Ayah which brings good news for those who repent after committing sins o my servants who have exceeded the limits

against their souls in other words my servants who have sinned excessively do not lose hope in Allah's Mercy for Allah certainly forgives all sins he forgives all sins is it reasonable that Allah would want to burn you could he have created you just to burn you there is hell and there are many such questions that people ask about it we shot this video to answer some of those frequently asked questions allies infinitely compassionate and merciful Allah wants to put us into heaven thank you